A car driving through a spooky road of trees

Ghost Stories and Our Search for Truth

This essay was written by Jorja Webb, a BYU Humanities Center student fellow.

I know it’s past Halloween, but I want to talk about ghost stories.  I’ve had little exposure to them; my experience is limited to specters meant to frighten around campfires and entertain in novels. In both these contexts, the supernatural always had an element of fantasy, and with it, an implicit falsity. Recently, though, I sat in the backseat of a car, listening to an esteemed friend share how a ghost once covered her grandma’s kitchen floor in an inch of butter. The passenger seat resident, another friend, nodded earnestly. She contributed her own frustration with mischievous ghosts, who ran riot in her neighborhood, regularly moving and hiding belongings.  

This straightforward conversation in the light of day was new to me. I’d always thought of ghosts as outside the bounds of reality, let alone a person’s everyday life, but my two companions were completely frank. To them, ghosts were quotidian nuisances. 

My friends’ tone was not dissimilar to my grandma’s when she’s shared experiences of feeling my grandpa’s presence, despite the fact that he passed away over twenty years ago. In our religious tradition, experiences with loved ones who have passed on are considered fully plausible, while ghost stories are placed in a completely different, and entirely fictional, category. I was surprised by how my friends’ conversation took the attitude I’m used to hearing in a religious context and expanded it onto the supernatural. 

Thinking about these accounts, and urged on by the Halloween season, I’ve questioned my attitude toward ghost stories. Should I approach them with the facetious fear of a camper, the unflinching and unquestioning attitude of my friends, or the reverence that my grandma expresses, though she would never classify her experiences as ghostly? I’d always thought of ghost stories as false: distinct from sacred, sincere experiences with the dead. But after the car conversation, the line between the two categories began to blur for me. 

One thing in common between my friends’ and my grandma’s accounts is the certainty of the person who experienced them. Their sincerity reminded of one of my favorite ghost stories: Henry James’ The Turn of the Screw. When I read the novella, it was late at night, and I found myself moving to face away from my house’s black windows as the governess descended deeper and deeper into her obsession with the house’s past inhabitants. As ghostly figures appeared, threatening her charges, I closed my curtains. For the first time in a long time, a ghost story actually scared me; it felt real, even in my shabby college kitchen.  

There’s a strangeness to the story that stems not from the ghosts, but from the governess herself. While she remains convinced of her experience, it’s unclear to the reader if the governess really saw the ghosts or if they were signs of her worsening mental state and obsessive tendencies. In class, my professor (Dr. Cutler) questioned our perception of the truthfulness of her experience. To others, the ghosts may not have appeared, but they were present in the governess’ mind, and they effected change through her actions. He taught us about relativism—the idea that truth is not fixed but is determined by the perspective of the individual. So, while the ghosts may or may not have been present, James’ protagonist truthfully saw them. And just like the governess, my grandma’s and friends’ stories are based in the certainty of their individual witnesses.  

Another story by Henry James, “The Jolly Corner,”  features a similar subjective encounter. In it, Spencer Bryden returns to his childhood home, a place that is now rightfully his but which he abandoned to live abroad. The story’s title sounds like a pleasant romp, and at first, it is. Then, Bryden starts to see an uncanny figure when he visits the house after dark. Night after night, the figure appears on the stairs or in a doorway, until finally Bryden sees it fully: “a man of his own substance and stature.” The ghost slowly lowers white hands to reveal a face that is Bryden’s own: the ghost is a part of himself, as neglected and twisted as the house he left behind. Bryden is so shaken by this reveal that he faints. Like in the other stories, only Bryden stands as a witness to the veracity of his experience. And whether his encounter with the ghost is real or imagined, it has tangible effects on his life. The confrontation leads Bryden to finally put down roots in his neighborhood, falling in love with his childhood friend Alice, who already understands and loves his entire self. As the catalyst for their relationship, the eerie experience was a net good. James demonstrates how supernatural stories, regardless of their veracity, may expose truths that lead to concrete consequences. An experience with real effects cannot be dismissed as laughable, the way ghost stories often are. 

In the car, I was intrigued to hear similar positive consequences of my friend’s ghost story. It seemed that her family bonded through their experiences, both in sharing their run-ins with the apparition and in eventually calming its outbursts. I’ve grown up hearing how my grandma’s continued connection to my grandpa had brought our family closer together, but I’d never considered how ghost stories could have a similar effect. Each narrative communicates truth: Henry James’ protagonists learned about the darkest defects in themselves, my friends witnessed the strong ties of some past resident to their home or neighborhood, and my grandma testified of the love that still links her with her sweetheart. The truths underlined by each encounter impacted real-world relationships, regardless of outside skepticism. Surprising to me, only the governess and her charges experienced negative effects from a ghostly experience; every other story had positive outcomes. 

Thinking back to my experience in the car, I understand that the subjective nature of my companions’ stories doesn’t make them any less true. As believers in a religious tradition that is so focused on pursuing truth, approaching reality through the lens of individual experience can be valuable. In my personal faith journey, it’s been revolutionary to learn that an experience need not be verifiable to be true or to generate good outcomes. Allowing for this possibility can strengthen our own confidence in personal witnesses and allow us to be more accepting of others’ experiences, even those which we may have initially been suspicious of. While I still don’t know how to answer the question, “Do you believe in ghosts?,” I can say that as I approach my friends’ ghostly encounters and my grandma’s sacred experiences with the same open mindset, I do believe I’ll encounter more truth.  

 

References

[1] James, Henry. The Turn of the Screw. Collier’s Weekly, 1898.

[2] James, Henry. “The Jolly Corner.” The English Review (Vol. 1, No. 1), 1908.

Popular Articles...